When organizing large quantities of resources and information in the digital world… putting things into groups, determining what goes where and assigning boundaries, it can be helpful to look at the real world for lessons learned. Imposing boundaries in unnatural locations is bound to fail sooner or later, the results can be disastrous taking generations to overcome.
Take for example Southern Africa. Oceans, mountains, deserts, vegetation and other natural features determined where people lived and worked.
Over time, people settled in various areas surrounded by their culture. Learning the best ways to be productive based on the conditions in their area – whether it was a jungle with vast resources or a desert with very few.
From Africa Expat
Ancient people such as the Shona in modern day Zimbabwe congregated and stuck together in different areas. Many of these languages and traditions continue today. But these curving, natural, and emergent boundaries don’t match boundaries imposed from outside cultures.
From Wikimedia Commons
Occasionally, an imposed boundary may coincide with a natural boundary such as a river. More often though, imposed boundaries are designed to work within larger more global schemes, without paying enough attention to the local impact.
From Wikimedia Commons
Anyone can see where arbitrarily drawing lines has gotten us today. What can be learned from history to avoid similar situations in the fresh, clean, brand new digital world where ideas and information are still patterning out and have no where in particular to belong except where they are emerging as “next to something else” or arranged for convenient, all encompassing, upper level views
Linked Open Data, Colored, as of March 2009
What about situations where digital terrain and intellectual data boundaries are being purposefully laid out. For example Master Web of Science, mapofscience.com and Places & Spaces where navigating the data is like exploring uncharted territory, and Katy Borner and collaborators seek to enable the discovery of new worlds while also marking territories inhabited by unknown monsters.
The difference in the semantic world versus the physical world should be that the digital world has no constraints like rivers or mountains. Eventually all of the layout can be determined. Attention does need to be paid to where cultures are emerging, and how this can benefit everyone both globally and locally.
Not only watch how the semantic web is emerging, but to direct it’s flow in productive ways, geared for people in different areas that may vary widely in their density and resources, rather than as one empire. Because that only causes trouble in the long run.
Random Layout Algorithm at Cell System Markup Language (CSML) an XML format for modeling, visualizing and simulating biopathways.
The advantage of paying attention to this is, reaching an appropriate balance between random emergence and directed flow will ultimately serve end users and programmers better than any other option, and the solutions will last for a long time.